Working papers
Effects of Subsidies on Welfare and Market Structure in the U.S. Broadband Industry
Abstract
How should governments allocate broadband subsidies between affordability support and infrastructure deployment? I study the Affordable Connectivity Program (ACP) and the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program, combining state-year event studies with a tract-level structural model of demand, pricing, and entry estimated on broadband products across 66,454 census tracts using FCC, ACS, and NTIA data. In high-eligibility states, ACP reduced prices by roughly 7–10 percent at peak, shifted plans toward faster speeds, and lowered concentration; BEAD's effects are smaller and delayed, consistent with construction lags. Because the two programs target different market failures and geographies, their returns are not directly comparable: counterfactual simulations imply a lifetime-discounted benefit-cost ratio of roughly 26–27 for BEAD, where long-lived infrastructure reaches previously unserved areas, compared with 1.01–1.03 for ACP under targeted eligibility in already-served markets. The optimal policy mix therefore depends on the binding constraint: deployment where infrastructure is absent, affordability where service exists but remains out of reach.
Efficient and Debiased Estimation of Dynamic Discrete Choice Models
Abstract
This paper introduces a new method that integrates machine learning techniques with traditional econometric tools to correct bias in two-step estimation for dynamic discrete choice models under incomplete information. Unlike most existing approaches that primarily address bias from conditional choice probabilities while taking the transition matrix as given, this method simultaneously addresses both sources of bias. I propose a two-step estimator that jointly includes the conditional choice probabilities and transition matrix as first-step estimates, providing a robust, non-iterative solution. The estimator achieves square root N consistency and asymptotic efficiency. In addition, I establish a simple connection between Neyman orthogonality and the Zero-Jacobian property, a key result that guarantees consistent and efficient estimators in single-agent models. Monte Carlo simulations using a common benchmark data-generating process demonstrate the good performance of the proposed method.
Target-Population Fragility in Judge IV under Average Monotonicity
Abstract
Judge-IV designs increasingly invoke average monotonicity when strong monotonicity is hard to defend. We show that average monotonicity does not preserve a stable target population: the response types receiving positive weight switch discretely when a judge’s treatment propensity crosses the assignment-weighted average, so when the switching types are present in the population and have distinct average treatment effects, the estimand need not be locally invariant. We propose a diagnostic that measures each judge’s standardized distance to this boundary. In the Philadelphia bail data, three of eight judges, handling about 29 percent of cases, lie near the boundary. Target-population stability is therefore an empirical object once average monotonicity is invoked.
Work in progress
Fintech Entry and Agent Selection in Mobile Money Markets: Evidence from Senegal
Abstract
What determines where a fintech entrant builds its agent network, and does incumbent deterrence bind that reach? I study Wave’s entry into Senegal’s mobile money market against three telecom incumbents — Orange, Free, and Expresso — using a retail audit of 1,550 stores and a static entry game with moment inequalities (Ciliberto and Tamer 2009), leaving equilibrium selection unrestricted. The audit shows that Wave reaches 13.8 percent of stores overall but 75.9 percent of dedicated transfer outlets and 54.5 percent of stores with smartphone-owning operators; coverage concentrates where agents already handle transfers and own smartphones, not where incumbents are absent. Estimates imply that transfer outlets raise Wave’s payoff by 1.69 and smart- phone readiness has an identified set of [1.49, 1.85]. Fintech entry lowers Free’s payoff (δ ∈ [−0.49, −0.01]) but is not identified away from zero for Expresso ([−0.75, 0.16]). Universal smartphone readiness would nearly triple Wave’s coverage with negligible incumbent displacement. The binding constraint on fintech diffusion is not strategic deterrence, but agents’ digital capacity.
Selection on Structural Errors in Moment-Inequality Estimation of Discrete Games
Abstract
Observed action profiles in discrete games condition on structural errors known to players, contaminating best-response moment inequalities. Semiparametric matching cannot remove this selection for equilibrium inequalities: the payoff index that identifies the parameter is the same threshold that determines selection, so matching finely enough to equalize selection also removes the variation needed for identification. Two positive results follow. First, we show that Ahn--Powell differencing survives for post-entry outcome equations once the scalar propensity score gives way to the vector of players' choice propensities. Second, we derive a Hardy--Littlewood envelope that bounds the selection term using only a known marginal shock distribution, yielding valid moment inequalities under arbitrary dependence and equilibrium selection. Simulations and Senegal fintech data show that naive moments can produce an empty identified set, whereas the proposed bounds yield a nonempty and economically interpretable set.
Semiparametric Identification and Estimation in Binary Choice Models
Abstract
We leverage a convex programming strategy and propose a new approach to estimating binary choice models that is robust to standard parametric specification assumptions.